Martin Zarate ([info]pxtl) wrote,
@ 2008-03-07 19:29:00
Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend  Next Entry
Current music:none... yet.
Entry tags:music, rant, shopping

Ghosts, FLAC
Nine Inch Nails once again proved that they (he?) are the coolest people (person?)* on the planet. The latest album, Ghosts I-IV (a 36-track series) is sold online for $5. So, last night I picked it up in FLAC lossless. For $5. No DRM, no quality degradation, just 600 megs of pure above-CD sound.

And then, to play it and get it onto my iPod.

Crap.

For those who don't know, FLAC is a sound/music file format that is perfect, and well-compressed. Handy to have for your master-copies - you can make degraded versions from there. MP3 has better compatibility and is much smaller per-file, but if you convert from a high-quality MP3 into another format, it will degrade. FLAC will not. I figured "I'm a nerd, I should get the FLAC and transcode a copy into MP3 for my ipod and other players".

Seemed easy enough.

Until I found out that none of the mainstream apps have 1st-party support for FLAC, despite it being the standard for lossless. Then I went looking for opensource tools (my typical second-choice after free MS products). Double-crap. The OSS tools are little command-line Perl scripts that were designed for Linux and seem to complain about various missing dependancies on Windows XP - I even went to the trouble of installing ActiveState Perl onto my machine to run them.

So, I ended up fetching Foobar2000 - a decent freeware app. Still, I wince at using freeware, because you always worry about getting what you paid for, and since it's closed-source, you don't know what's inside.

Foobar2000 is actually surprisingly nice - it feels like a stripped-down iTunes using the Windows native interface, with far more power-user-friendly features. It's happily grinding away at converting my unreadable (but archive-quality) FLAC files into MP3s.

* NIN is a band... but it's a band of hired guns run by the owner, composer, lead performer, etc. that is Trent Reznor. So I often think it's kinda silly to refer to it as a band when he does more than most singer-songwriters.




(3 comments) - (Post a new comment)


[info]nfotxn
2008-03-08 01:33 am UTC (link)
Use something like Goldwave, Audacity or even Winamp's disk writer plugin to output to wave, aiff or another common uncompressed format. Import that into iTunes and re-encode into Apple Lossless. It's a format iTunes and your iPod support natively, no DRM and QuickTime Pro will transcode into whatever you'd like. Ta-da. No compression or signal loss in the chain.

The whole deal with Apple's media tools is that it's an ecosystem. Use their specs and it's painless. Avoid their DRM and it's totally painless. Bring in something external and it's painful. However there are QuickTime pluggins for flac on the Mac.

(Reply to this) (Thread)

Yeah.
[info]pxtl
2008-03-08 08:21 pm UTC (link)
Hindsight is 20-20 - the download was also available in Apple Lossless, but I figured FLAC was the most "open" format so it seemed like the safest bet. Either way, FooBar2000 did a fine job of transcoding.

Besides, I try to avoid overrelying on Apple for media, not because of any particular gripe, but simply because I've found that the Windows version of iTunes is the worst piece-of-crap that I've ever had the misfortune of using.

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)

Re: Yeah.
[info]nfotxn
2008-03-08 08:24 pm UTC (link)
Oh I make no defence for the Windows version of QuickTime. Some friends who were QA for MSFT were telling me horror stories. But then again they couldn't base it on Windows Media because that is a whole new gulag of problems.

All I can say is that compared to QuickTime on the Mac there is nothing as similar on Windows. I can easily transcode from anything to anything and get it right. It even has cute little live previews so you don't kill 2hrs transcoding a movie and have it cropped wrong or something retarded.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


(3 comments) - (Post a new comment)

Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Login w/ OpenID
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…